Savor the Nostalgia of Yesteryear
Discover a unique collection of vintage toys, rare finds, and timeless gifts right here in Elyria, Ohio. Every item tells a story waiting to be heard.
Authentic & Rare
Every piece is verified for authenticity and condition.
Carefully Packaged
We treat every item with the respect it deserves.
Family Owned
Proudly serving the Elyria community for over a decade.
Curated Treasures
From tin robots to porcelain dolls, our selection is hand-picked for quality and nostalgia.
Classic Tin Robots
Authentic mechanics from the golden age of sci-fi. Wind them up and watch them go!
Antique Plush Bears
Loved, restored, and ready for a new home. Soft companions with a century of hugs.
Die-Cast Models
Precision detailed cars from the 50s and 60s. Perfect for your desk or display case.
Shop by Era
Travel through time and find the toys that defined a generation.
Collectors' Voices
Hear from fellow enthusiasts who have found their missing pieces with us.
"I finally found the 1954 robot I've been searching for over a decade. The condition was pristine and the packaging was incredibly secure."
"Walking into Elyria Vintage Toys is like stepping into a time machine. I bought a bear for my granddaughter and she adores it."
"Expert knowledge and fair prices. It's rare to find a shop that cares this much about the history behind the items."
More Than Just a Store
Located at 272 Vassar Ave, Elyria, Ohio, we are a family-owned destination for collectors and gift-givers alike. We believe that every toy has a story, and we are dedicated to preserving the history of play.
Founded on a passion for the past, Elyria Vintage Toys began as a small personal collection and grew into a haven for anyone looking to relive their childhood. Whether you are looking for that specific piece to complete your collection or a unique gift that stands out, our knowledgeable staff is here to help you travel back in time.
Read Our StoryFrequently Asked Questions
Do you buy vintage toys?
Yes, we are always interested in acquiring high-quality vintage toys. Please contact us to schedule an appraisal.
Do you ship internationally?
Currently, we ship within the United States. Please contact us for special inquiries.
What is your return policy?
We offer a 14-day return policy for store credit on extensive items, verified upon inspection.
Are your items authentic?
Absolutely. We guarantee the authenticity of every vintage item we sell.